Sharing is caring!

If you love thoughtful gifting without the high price tag—or the clutter—second-hand gifts are the perfect fit. As a frugal-minded, simple-living family, we’ve embraced the beauty of giving items that are sustainable, budget-friendly, and full of life. Whether you’re shopping for birthdays, holidays, or special milestones, this Second-Hand Gift Guide will help you find meaningful gifts while staying true to your values.

Why Choose Second-Hand Gifts?

Second-hand gifting supports three things many families care deeply about:

1. Frugal Living Without Sacrificing Quality

New doesn’t always mean better. You can find gently-used, high-quality items at a fraction of retail prices—sometimes 70–90% off.

2. Simple Living & Less Waste

Buying pre-loved reduces demand for fast-produced goods and keeps perfectly good items out of landfills.

3. More Thoughtful Gifting

Finding the just-right second-hand item feels like treasure hunting. It’s often more personal and unique than grabbing something off a big-box store shelf.

Where to Find the Best Second-Hand Gifts

Here are the most reliable (and budget-friendly!) places to shop for second-hand treasures.

1. Kids Consignment Sales (Especially Half-Off Days!)

Seasonal kids consignment sales are gold mines for gifts. These sales usually happen twice a year and are run by local parents who want to pass along gently used toys, books, clothing, puzzles, baby gear, STEM kits, decor, and more.

Why shop them for gifts?

• Items are often in excellent condition
• Huge selection in one place
• Perfect for children’s birthdays and Christmas
• Many sales offer half-off days, making prices unbelievably low
• You can find “new-with-tags” gifts for just a few dollars

Pro tip: Bring a list of upcoming birthdays or clothing sizes so you can shop with purpose—simple living starts with intentional choices.

2. Kids Consignment Stores (Like Once Upon a Child)

If you don’t want to wait for the big seasonal sales, dedicated kids resale shops like Once Upon a Child are open year-round.

What makes them great?

• They consistently carry high-quality brands
• Most stores screen items carefully for condition
• You can grab last-minute gift options quickly
• Many locations run clearance sales or buy-one-get-one promotions

Gift ideas to look for:
⭐ Quality board books
⭐ Baby/toddler toys
⭐ Wooden puzzles
⭐ Dress-up clothes
⭐ Holiday outfits
⭐ Sports equipment
⭐ STEM toys and manipulatives

Buying second-hand here feels effortless—and it keeps your gift-giving affordable and clutter-light.

3. Online Thrift Stores (eBay, Poshmark, Kidizen, Mercari)

If you love variety or prefer shopping from home, online resale marketplaces are an incredible resource.

eBay

Great for collectibles, LEGO sets, vintage toys, discontinued board games, and name-brand clothing.

Kidizen

Perfect for boutique children’s clothing, high-quality shoes, and specialty toys.

Poshmark & Mercari

Excellent for clothing, accessories, and home décor.

Why online thrift shopping is ideal for gifts:

• Wide selection—almost anything you need is available used
• You can filter for new or “like-new” condition
• Prices are typically much lower than retail
• Great for finding niche or hard-to-find gift ideas

Search terms to try:
✨ “New with tags gift”
✨ “Like new toys”
✨ “Boutique kids clothing”
✨ “Complete set” (for puzzles/games)

4. Garage Sales & Yard Sales

If you enjoy a Saturday morning adventure, garage sales offer some of the absolute lowest prices you’ll find anywhere.

What makes them so good for gifting?

• People often undersell high-quality items just to declutter
• You can negotiate prices
• You may find big-ticket items—bikes, dollhouses, train tables—for $5–10
• Great for bundles: books, Hot Wheels, craft supplies, dolls, etc.

Garage-sale gifting tip:
Look for items in clean, excellent condition—or ones you can quickly clean up and make gift-ready.

Second-Hand Gift Ideas That Always Shine

Here are second-hand gifts that work beautifully for birthdays, Christmas, and even homeschool enrichment.

Kids & Family Gifts

• Wooden toys (Grimm’s, Melissa & Doug, Hape)
• Dress-up costumes
• Board books & chapter books
• Puzzles and educational games
• Bicycles, scooters, roller skates
• LEGO sets (just wash & dry thoroughly!)
• Art supplies (unused sets are extremely common)
• Dollhouses and accessories
• Sports equipment

Adults

• Coffee table books
• Kitchen tools and bakeware
• Vintage décor
• Cozy blankets
• Hobby tools (sewing, crafting, woodworking)
• High-quality bags or wallets
• Records or CDs for collectors

How to Make a Second-Hand Gift Feel Special

Even a thrifted gift can feel brand-new with a little presentation:

• Clean or sanitize the item
• Add fresh packaging (brown paper, twine, tissue paper)
• Pair it with something small and new (markers for a used art kit, new socks with second-hand ice skates)
• Include a handwritten note about why you chose it

Thoughtful touches matter more than price tags.

Second-Hand Gifts Are Smart, Simple, and Sustainable

Living frugally doesn’t mean giving less—it means giving better. Second-hand gifts are budget-friendly, eco-conscious, and often more meaningful than anything bought new. Whether you’re browsing kids consignment sales on half-off day, scrolling through eBay, or hunting treasures at a garage sale, you’ll find incredible items that fit your simple living values.

Embrace the joy of second-hand gifting—it’s one of the easiest (and most rewarding!) ways to live intentionally.